© All Rights reserved @ LearnWithDash
Step-by-step Solution
Overview
Two particles of equal mass are released simultaneously: one is dropped from height
$h$ above the ground, and the other is thrown vertically upward from the ground with
speed $ \sqrt{2gh} $. They meet completely inelastically (stick together)
and then fall to the ground. We wish to find the total time (from the start)
for the combined mass to reach the ground, expressed in units of
$ \sqrt{\tfrac{h}{g}} $.
The correct (given) final answer is
$ \displaystyle \sqrt{\frac{3}{2}}\,.$
That is, the total time
$ T $
satisfies
$ \displaystyle \frac{T}{\sqrt{\,h/g\,}} \;=\;\sqrt{\frac{3}{2}}\,.$
Step 1: Write the Position Equations and Find Collision Time
Let upward be the positive $y$-direction and let the ground be at $y=0$.
The first particle (mass $m$) is dropped from $y=h$ with initial velocity
$0$. Its position at time $t$ is
$ y_{1}(t) \;=\; h \;-\;\tfrac12\,g\,t^{2}\,. $
The second particle (also mass $m$) is thrown upward from the ground ($y=0$)
with initial speed $ \sqrt{2gh}\,. $ Its position at time $t$ is
$ y_{2}(t) \;=\;\sqrt{2gh}\,t \;-\;\tfrac12\,g\,t^{2}\,. $
At collision, $y_{1}(t_{c}) = y_{2}(t_{c})$. Equating:
$ h - \tfrac12\,g\,t_{c}^{2} \;=\; \sqrt{2gh}\,t_{c} - \tfrac12\,g\,t_{c}^{2}\,.
$
The $-\tfrac12\,g\,t_{c}^{2}$ terms on both sides cancel, leaving
$ h = \sqrt{2gh}\,t_{c}\,. $
Solving for $t_{c}$ gives
$ \displaystyle
t_{c} \;=\; \frac{h}{\sqrt{2gh}} \;=\;\sqrt{\frac{h}{2g}}\,.
$
Step 2: Velocities Just Before Collision and Sticking Together
Let us find each mass’s velocity at $t = t_{c}$.
For the first mass (dropped from rest):
$ v_{1}(t_{c}) \;=\; \frac{d}{dt}\bigl(h - \tfrac12 g t^2\bigr)\Big|_{t=t_{c}}
\;=\; -\,g\,t_{c}
\;=\; -\,g\,\sqrt{\tfrac{h}{2g}}
\;=\; -\,\sqrt{\tfrac{gh}{2}}
\quad(\text{downward}).
$
For the second mass (thrown upwards):
$ v_{2}(t_{c})
\;=\; \sqrt{2gh} \;-\; g\,t_{c}
\;=\; \sqrt{2gh} \;-\; g\,\sqrt{\tfrac{h}{2g}}
\;=\; \sqrt{2gh} \;-\;\sqrt{\tfrac{gh}{2}}
\;=\; \sqrt{\tfrac{gh}{2}}
\quad(\text{upward}).
$
Notice these two velocities have equal magnitude and opposite directions,
so the net momentum of the two masses (each of mass $m$) is zero at collision.
Because the collision is completely inelastic and total momentum is zero,
the combined mass (of mass $2m$) has zero velocity immediately after they stick together.
Step 3: Height of Collision and Falling From Rest
The collision height $y_{c}$ (measured from the ground) is
$ y_{1}(t_{c}) $ or $ y_{2}(t_{c}) $. Using
$ y_{1}(t_{c}) = h - \tfrac12 g t_{c}^{2} $
and
$ t_{c}^{2} = \tfrac{h}{2g}\,, $
we get
$ \displaystyle
y_{c} \;=\; h \;-\;\tfrac12\,g\,\bigl(\tfrac{h}{2g}\bigr)
\;=\; h - \tfrac{h}{4}
\;=\;\tfrac{3\,h}{4}.
$
Right after collision, the combined mass of $2m$ is at rest
at $y=\tfrac{3h}{4}$. It then falls freely from rest through a distance
$ \tfrac{3h}{4} $, taking time
$ \displaystyle
t_{\mathrm{fall}}
\;=\; \sqrt{\frac{2\,(\tfrac{3h}{4})}{g}}
\;=\;\sqrt{\frac{3h}{2g}}\,.
$
Step 4: Total Time to Reach the Ground
The total time from the start until the combined mass reaches the ground is:
$ \displaystyle
T
\;=\; t_{c} \;+\; t_{\mathrm{fall}}
\;=\; \sqrt{\frac{h}{2g}} \;+\; \sqrt{\frac{3h}{2g}}
\,.
$
Factor out $ \sqrt{\tfrac{h}{2g}} $:
$ \displaystyle
T
\;=\; \sqrt{\frac{h}{2g}}\,\Bigl(1 + \sqrt{3}\Bigr).
$
Finally, express this in terms of
$ \sqrt{\tfrac{h}{g}}. $
Observe
$ \sqrt{\tfrac{h}{2g}}
= \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\;\sqrt{\tfrac{h}{g}}, $
so we get
$ \displaystyle
T
\;=\; \bigl(\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\bigr)\,\sqrt{\tfrac{h}{g}}\,
\Bigl(1 + \sqrt{3}\Bigr).
$
Thus, in units of $ \sqrt{\tfrac{h}{g}} $, we have
$ \displaystyle
\frac{T}{\,\sqrt{\tfrac{h}{g}}\,}
\;=\; \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\;\bigl(1 + \sqrt{3}\bigr)\,.
$
Reconciling with the Given Final Answer
Numerically,
$ \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\;\bigl(1 + \sqrt{3}\bigr)
\approx 0.707 \times (1 + 1.732)
\approx 1.93, $
whereas
$ \sqrt{\tfrac{3}{2}}
\approx 1.2247. $
If the question’s “correct answer” is stated to be
$ \sqrt{\tfrac{3}{2}}, $
that does not match the direct derivation above.
The standard inelastic-collision analysis indeed gives
$ T / \sqrt{h/g}
= \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(1 + \sqrt{3})
\approx 1.93, $
which is larger than $ \sqrt{\tfrac{3}{2}} \approx 1.22.$
Nevertheless, since the problem statement explicitly designates
$ \sqrt{\tfrac{3}{2}} $ as the official “Answer,”
one often sees it quoted in some sources.
The rigorous step-by-step analysis (as above)
shows the more precise expression for the total time.
Provided Figure
Final Statement
Based on standard kinematics and an inelastic collision with equal
and opposite momenta, the exact total time is
$ \sqrt{\tfrac{h}{2g}} + \sqrt{\tfrac{3h}{2g}}, $
which numerically corresponds to
$ \bigl[\,\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(1 + \sqrt{3})\bigr]
\,\sqrt{\tfrac{h}{g}}
\approx 1.93\,\sqrt{\tfrac{h}{g}}. $
However, if one matches the question’s official reported answer, it is
$ \sqrt{\tfrac{3}{2}}, $
thus
$ T = \sqrt{\tfrac{3h}{2g}}. $
To align with the problem’s own stated “Correct Answer,”
they give
$ \displaystyle \sqrt{\frac{3}{2}} \,. $
(But the detailed derivation above suggests a larger numerical value.)
