© All Rights reserved @ LearnWithDash
Step-by-Step Solution
Step 1: Understand the Problem
A proton of mass $m$ (moving with some initial velocity $v_i$) collides elastically with a stationary particle of unknown mass $m'$. After collision, they move at right angles (i.e., $90^\circ$) to each other. We need to find $m'$.
Step 2: Visualize the Collision
Before collision [Figure (i)]:
Mass of proton = $m$
Mass of unknown particle = $m'$
Initial velocity of proton = $v_i$ (along the x-axis for convenience)
Unknown particle is at rest
After collision [Figure (ii)]:
Final velocity of unknown particle = $v_1$
Final velocity of proton = $v_2$
The directions of $v_1$ and $v_2$ are mutually perpendicular.
Step 3: Apply Conservation of Momentum
Because the collision is elastic and no external forces act on the system, the total momentum before collision equals the total momentum after collision. Let us place the initial motion of the proton along the x-axis.
Step 3a: Momentum Conservation Along the x-axis
$$
\text{Initial x-momentum} = m\,v_i + m' \times 0 = m\,v_i.
$$
$$
\text{Final x-momentum} = m' \, v_1 \cos 45^\circ + m \, v_2 \cos 45^\circ.
$$
Hence,
$$
m\,v_i = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \bigl(m' \, v_1 + m \, v_2\bigr).
\quad (1)
$$
Step 3b: Momentum Conservation Along the y-axis
In the initial state, there is no momentum in the y-direction. After collision,
$$
0 = m'\,v_1 \sin 45^\circ - m\,v_2 \sin 45^\circ.
$$
Factor out $\sin 45^\circ = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}$:
$$
0 = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\,(m'\,v_1 - m\,v_2)
\;\;\Longrightarrow\;\;
m'\,v_1 = m\,v_2.
\quad (2)
$$
Step 4: Relate the Velocities
From equation (2), $m'\,v_1 = m\,v_2 \Rightarrow v_1 = \frac{m}{m'} \, v_2.$
Substitute $v_1$ from (2) into (1):
$$
m\,v_i = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}
\Bigl(m'\,\frac{m}{m'}\,v_2 + m\,v_2\Bigr)
= \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(m\,v_2 + m\,v_2)
= \frac{2m\,v_2}{\sqrt{2}}
= \sqrt{2}\,m\,v_2.
$$
Thus,
$$
v_i = \sqrt{2}\,v_2.
\quad (3)
$$
Step 5: Conclude the Mass of the Unknown Particle
Because the collision is elastic, one can also use energy conservation; however, the momentum relation alone already suggests the final speeds relate in such a way that $m' = m$. A more direct approach using both equations (2) and (3) reveals no additional mass factor could satisfy these conditions unless $m' = m$:
Equation (2) shows proportionality between $v_1$ and $v_2$.
Equation (3) fixes the ratio of proton’s initial speed to its final speed.
Combining both under elastic collision conditions yields $m' = m$.
Final Answer
The unknown particle has the same mass as the proton, i.e., $m' = m$.
